Judge Middleton’s Courtroom Rules

One of Judge Middleton's campaign promises was to increase professional standards and clarity. His standing orders reflect a focus on efficiency and strict adherence to the Uniform Superior Court Rules.

1. Motion Hearings

Unlike some judges who hear every motion in person, Judge Middleton does not routinely grant oral arguments for all motions.

The Process: You must write a letter to the judge explaining why an oral hearing is necessary.
Decisions: Many motions are decided "on the briefs" (based solely on the written paperwork) unless a hearing is required by law (like for Summary Judgment).

2. Digital vs. Physical Filing

Attorneys are required to provide hard copies of motions and responses directly to the judge’s staff if they are seeking a specific ruling or hearing date. This must be done within 24 hours of the electronic filing.

3. Professionalism & Preparation

Judge Middleton expects high levels of preparation. For final hearings or trials, parties must submit several documents at least three business days in advance, including:

Domestic Financial Affidavits (for family law)
Witness and Exhibit Lists
Requests to Charge (jury instructions)

4. Communication Ethics

The court has a strict policy against ex parte communication. This means you cannot call the judge’s office to discuss the "merits" of a case or ask for legal advice. His staff—specifically his secretary and calendar clerk—are the primary points of contact for scheduling only.